Arcidiacono ended his career 15th all-time in NCAA Division III career rushing yards, with 4,191 career yards. He was the East Regional Finalist for the 2006 Gagliardi Trophy, for the player of the year in NCAA Division III. Arcidiacono averaged 6.4 yards per carry and 149.7 per game during the regular season. He rushed for 1,357 yards and 19 rushing TDs, and ended his career ranked 15th all-time in NCAA Division III career rushing yards with 4,919. He recently ranked second nationally in scoring, third in rushing and fifth in all-purpose yards. Arcidiacono is an inner-city school tutor and counsels on drug and alcohol awareness. He was named the Liberty League Offensive Performer of the Year for the second straight season. Arcidiacono will play for the AFCA's Division III all-star team that will represent the United States against the Mexican National Team in the 2006 Aztec Bowl this Saturday, December 16 in Aguascalientes, Mexico. He was named a First Team All-American in 2006 by the American Football Coaches Association.
In 2005, Arcidiacono rushed for an average of 162.8 yards a game on his way to a 2,067 yard season over 12 games. He had 350 rushing attempts, with 20 Touchdowns in the '05 season, and added 67 receiving yards on seven catches. Arcidiacono was the 2005 Liberty League Offensive Player of the Year, as well as on the 1st team All Stars. His other honors include being named to the Associated Press "Little" All American 3rd Team, the D3Football All American 1st Team, the Football Gazette All American 1st team, the ECAC Div. III Northwest All Star 1st Team, the D3Football All-East Region 1st Team, and the Football Gazette Division III All-East Region 1st Team. He was also a two time Liberty League Offensive Performer of the Week, an ECAC 2005 Division III Northwest Player of the Week, and a D3Football.com National Team of the Week.